Supporting the value of information in your enterprise

FreePint BlogInformation overload: fact, fantasy or filter failure?

Wednesday, 23rd May 2012 Please login top-right to be able to star items

By Michelle Manafy


Information overload is a figment of your imagination. Or a failure of your filter. Or a symptom of your technological submissiveness. Depends on who you ask.


Information overload is a figment of your imagination. Or a failure of your filter. Or a symptom of your technological submissiveness. Depends on who you ask.

When you consider overload from a numbers perspective, it seems like a genuine problem: According to IDC and EMC research 1.8 zettabytes of information were created and replicated in 2011. That daunting number set to double this year. If you are like most people, getting a clear picture of 1.8ZB won't be easy. A zettabyte is 1 billion gigabytes, but Mashable created a nice infographic that paints a clearer picture. For example, if every person in the United States Tweeted three tweets per minute for 26,976 years non-stop, they would generate 1.8ZB of information.  

Given the sheer volume of data, how is it that Altimeter Group's Brian Solis has just written about "The Fallacy of Information Overload"? Seems real enough to most of us who are flooded with information. Mind you, that sentiment "isn't a new phenomenon by any means. The sensation of being overwhelmed by information has been linked to every media revolution," according to Solis. However he says that "the symptoms of information overload are only a reflection of our inability or lack of desire to bring order to our chaos." He cites Clay Shirky's famous comment that "There's no such thing as information overload – only filter failure."

Yet as Tony Schwartz wrote on the HBR blog the same week, people are "struggling to manage what feels more and more like a tsunami – information coming at us in wave after wave, threatening to overwhelm everything else in our lives." Like Solis, he points out that this is not a new feeling. Schwartz quotes Nobel Prizing winning economist Herbert Simon's comment from 1970: "What information consumes is rather obvious. It consumes the attention of the recipients. Hence a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention."

While Solis drops in Shirky's memorable meme in as support of his fallacy premise, the larger context is essential to understand what he means by filter. Shirky isn't blaming the victim; he’s not suggesting that people are too lazy or inept to properly filter information. Rather, he illustrates how the increasing democratisation of the ability to create information (which started with the Gutenberg press) has created an ever-lower threshold for what gets published, yielding an increasingly unfiltered and unfettered flow of information.

While digital technologies have made it easier than ever to create and consume information, Schwartz believes that "Technology has no business setting our agenda, but it has turned into our dominatrix... we submit to it, emailing, texting, tweeting, searching Google, checking Facebook..." He also wisely points out that despite our affinity for technology, we are not computers. And that "what makes human beings unique is our capacity for reflection."

He's right: We are not computers. And most people's brains don't function like filters. Certainly, there are those among us who parse the stuff quickly. But you should be able to rely on trusted information creators to offer some filtering help. Here at FreePint, our Article Categories are a step in that direction. We also provide "useful if you work in" tags so that you can quickly skim content in our newsletters and PDF publications to more easily identify what might be of value to you and your team.

As Solis says, "We are obligated to maintain balance in who we are, what we value, and equally the value we invest in the communities in which we participate." Knowing what you, our readers, value is important, so we welcome your feedback via email or article comments at any time. We look forward to continuing to return your investment in the FreePint community. 


About this item:

Click to visit the FreePint Blog Related FreePint Blog items:

Item Topic Category:

View all Topic Categories »

Michelle Manafy is the senior editor of Min, which publishes the Media Industry Newsletter — the go-to resources for advertising data, news, deals, trends and personnel moves shaping the consumer magazine publishing industry — and hosts the industry's premier events and awards programs. Previously, Michelle held the position of Editor-in-chief at Free Pint Limited, a global publisher of sites, research and resources that support the value of information in the enterprise. Prior to joining FreePint, Michelle served as the Editorial Director of the Enterprise Group for Information Today, Inc. where she was editor of EContent Magazine and chair of the Buying & Selling eContent Conference and Enterprise Search Summits. She is the co-editor of and a contributor to the book Dancing With Digital Natives: Staying in Step With the Generation That's Transforming the Way Business is Done (May 2011, CyberAge Books). An award-winning columnist, Michelle's focus is on emerging trends in digital content and how they shape successful business practices. She speaks at a variety of industry events and serves as a judge for content and technology competitions. She has worked in book and magazine publishing for more than 20 years in areas ranging from pop culture to academic nonfiction and holds a BA in journalism from San Francisco State University.

More articles by Michelle Manafy »

« See all FreePint Blog items

FreePint Topics
Sources: Staying informed and aware
Technology: Improving information work with technology
Value: Maximising value for information work and investment
FreePint Newsletter

Keep up-to-date with the latest FreePint articles and tips by email twice a month.

Email address:

Newsletter 396
10th April 2014

FreePint NewsletterWe highlight details of our latest product reviews, webinars & consulting projects. Find out about upcoming Community of Practice sessions.

Register free »
Newsletter archive »

Have a FreePint Subscription?

"Yes, we subscribe"

Login to MyFreePint to access purchased content, be able to 'star' items, and to share items with your colleagues.

"No, not yet"

Find out more about the benefits of accessing all our premium articles, reports, webinars, communities of practice and consulting, through a FreePint Subscription

Keep up-to-date by signing up for the FreePint Newsletter.

"Don't know"

Contact us and we'll check if someone in your organisation has already purchased a subscription.

FreePint Subscription

A FreePint Subscription gives access to all FreePint content (articles, reports and webinars), Communities of Practice and consulting. Find out more.